When Honesty Becomes a Disadvantage

Integrity, Credibility, and Leadership in the Pastoral Search Process
We live in a culture in which dishonesty increasingly seems to carry fewer consequences than telling the truth. Political leaders make demonstrably false claims and continue to command loyal followings. Business leaders exaggerate accomplishments, public figures manufacture narratives of success, and misinformation spreads so freely that people sometimes struggle to distinguish what is true from what they want to believe.
Christian B. Miller, a philosopher at Wake Forest University and former director of its Honesty Project, examines this troubling development in his recent book, The Honesty Crisis. Miller argues that dishonesty flourishes when people have strong incentives to deceive and believe they can get away with it.[1]
When deception becomes an effective strategy, honesty can begin to look like a competitive disadvantage.
The church is not immune to these pressures. Public confidence in its leaders is already fragile. In Gallup's December 2025 survey, only 27 percent of Americans rated clergy highly for honesty and ethical standards, the lowest figure in the history of the survey.[2] That finding does not establish that clergy are becoming more dishonest, but it does tell us something important about the trust we can no longer take for granted.
One place I have watched the tension between honesty and success develop over more than three decades of pastoral ministry is in the pastoral search process.
I have encountered clergy résumés and personal profiles containing inflated accomplishments, misleading accounts of ministry, and sometimes claims that are simply untrue. I have also watched congregations construct expectations for their next pastor that no reasonable candidate could fulfill.
These problems feed one another.
Congregations describe the extraordinary leader they hope to find. Candidates, understandably eager to receive a call, present themselves as the answer to those hopes. Accomplishments are magnified, limitations fade from view, and complicated histories of ministry become polished narratives of personal success.
Not every exaggeration is deliberate deception. Some pastors may have come to believe their own accounts of what happened. Others feel pressure to compete with candidates whose profiles promise remarkable results. But whatever the explanation, a pastoral relationship built on misleading expectations begins with a deficit of trust.
How does an honest pastor compete in a process that sometimes rewards exaggeration?
And how might that pastor use the search process itself to demonstrate the integrity and leadership a congregation actually needs?
Consider what many congregations hope to find in their next pastor.
Someone who will increase attendance, attract younger families, improve stewardship, strengthen Christian education, provide excellent pastoral care, resolve conflict, expand community ministries, and lead the church into a promising future.
A gifted preacher, compassionate counselor, effective administrator, visionary leader, skilled teacher, and emotionally mature colleague.
Preferably, all these gifts will reside in one person with a history of exceptional success who is available at a salary the congregation can afford.
That pastor does not exist.
Certainly, some pastors possess extraordinary gifts. Others bring unusual combinations of experience, wisdom, and leadership ability. But no pastor excels at everything, and no pastor accomplishes the work of ministry alone.
Nevertheless, congregations frequently develop position descriptions that read more like inventories of their hopes than realistic assessments of their needs. Search committees may have limited experience evaluating pastoral leadership. They may also be anxious about declining membership, financial pressures, unresolved conflict, or the uncertainty that accompanies pastoral transition.
They are looking for someone who will help them believe the future can be different.
There is nothing wrong with hope. But hope becomes dangerous when it is confused with unrealistic expectations.
Candidates recognize these expectations. They study the congregational profile, identify the qualities the committee is seeking, and prepare to demonstrate that they possess them.
If the congregation wants growth, emphasize growth. If it wants conflict resolution, describe yourself as a reconciler. If it wants visionary leadership, highlight bold initiatives. If it wants stability, minimize the difficulties of previous ministries.
The temptation is to present the most attractive version of ourselves rather than the most truthful one.
Because pastoral searches are largely confidential, committees may have limited opportunities to examine the accuracy of those representations. References often answer narrowly framed questions, and committees may not know enough about a candidate's previous ministry to ask the questions that matter.
An impressive claim can therefore carry more weight than a careful, truthful account of experience.
Competence matters. Experience matters. Results matter. Pastors should be able to describe their accomplishments with confidence.
But an impressive account of ministry is not necessarily a trustworthy one.
Ministry Is Never a Solo Accomplishment
Suppose a search committee asks a candidate to describe a significant accomplishment.
The candidate responds:
"During my ministry, worship attendance increased by 40 percent, giving increased by 25 percent, and we established three new community ministries."
That may be entirely accurate. But what does it actually tell the committee?
What was happening in the congregation before the pastor arrived? What circumstances contributed to the growth? Who developed and led the new ministries? What role did the session play? How much of the increased giving reflected new generosity, and how much resulted from changes in membership or a major gift?
Most importantly, what did the pastor actually contribute?
An honest candidate might offer a more revealing account:
"When I arrived, the congregation had already begun developing a renewed commitment to community ministry. Several elders had strong relationships with local organizations, and a group of members was eager to experiment with new approaches. My contribution was helping them clarify their vision, work through disagreements, and organize their efforts into sustainable ministries. Over the next several years, attendance and giving increased substantially. I am grateful for what we accomplished together, and I learned a great deal about leadership from that experience."
The candidate has not diminished the accomplishment. The growth remains real. The pastor's contribution is clear. But the answer also reveals an understanding of congregational life, an ability to recognize the gifts of others, and a willingness to distinguish personal leadership from collective achievement.
The committee asked about an accomplishment. The candidate answered by demonstrating leadership.
A pastor does not have to wait for the right question to give an answer that reveals integrity.
The way we tell the story of our ministry may reveal more about our leadership than the accomplishment itself.
A pastor who understands how ministry actually happens can explain not only what was accomplished but also how people worked together, what obstacles they encountered, and what made the outcome possible.
That is a far more revealing account of leadership than a list of impressive statistics.
Every experienced pastor has known disappointment.
We have introduced initiatives that failed, misjudged situations, misunderstood people, and made decisions we later regretted. We have experienced conflict, resistance, exhaustion, and occasions when our best efforts were insufficient.
These experiences do not necessarily disqualify us from ministry. They are part of the ministry.
Yet candidates often approach interviews as though acknowledging failure would undermine their credibility.
I would suggest that the ability to reflect honestly on failure may be one of the clearest demonstrations of pastoral maturity.
Consider a familiar interview question: "How do you handle conflict?"
A candidate can offer a polished answer about active listening, collaboration, healthy communication, and finding common ground. Those are admirable practices, but nearly anyone can learn to describe them.
A more revealing response might begin:
"I have learned that my first understanding of a conflict is not always the most accurate. Earlier in ministry, I sometimes moved too quickly toward solutions before understanding what people were experiencing. In one situation, that contributed to the problem rather than resolving it. I have worked to become more patient, to listen for what is not being said, and to recognize how my own assumptions affect the conversation."
Such an answer does not suggest weakness. It demonstrates self-awareness, responsibility, and the capacity to learn.
It also opens the door to a more meaningful conversation.
The committee may ask what happened, what the pastor learned, and how that learning changed subsequent leadership. The interview moves beyond rehearsed descriptions of competence toward an exploration of character.
A pastor who can acknowledge a mistaken judgment without becoming defensive may be demonstrating precisely the kind of leadership a congregation needs when difficult decisions arise.
Of course, an interview should not become a public confession or a rehearsal of every painful experience. Nor should pastors feel obligated to betray confidences from previous ministries.
Honesty is not the same as telling everything.
A pastor can describe the dynamics of a difficult ministry without identifying individuals or disclosing protected information. A candidate can acknowledge that a pastoral relationship ended amid significant disagreements without assigning blame or revealing confidential proceedings.
Sometimes the most honest answer is:
"That was a complicated situation involving people whose privacy I am obligated to respect. I can tell you what my responsibilities were, how I approached the situation, what I learned, and what I would do differently."
Such an answer may not satisfy every committee member. But it demonstrates something essential to pastoral leadership: the capacity to be truthful while honoring obligations to others.
Trustworthiness includes knowing what we must not disclose.
An Interview Is the Beginning of a Pastoral Relationship
Pastoral interviews are often treated as examinations in which the committee asks questions and the candidate supplies acceptable answers.
But a pastoral call is not simply an employment decision. It is the beginning of a relationship between a pastor and a community of people who hope to discern and participate in God's work together.
That changes the conversation.
The candidate is not merely trying to persuade the committee to extend a call. The candidate is also helping the committee understand what a faithful pastoral relationship might require.
Even poorly framed questions can become opportunities for thoughtful leadership.
When a committee asks about leadership, a pastor can describe how leadership is shared, how decisions are discerned, and how people are equipped to exercise their gifts.
When it asks about accomplishments, a pastor can explain the relationships and circumstances that made those accomplishments possible.
When it asks about conflict, a pastor can demonstrate how to approach disagreement without assigning villains and heroes.
When it asks about vision, a pastor can explain that discerning a congregation's future requires listening, learning, and discovering what God may already be doing among its people.
And when a committee presents unrealistic expectations, a candidate can gently challenge them.
For example:
"You have described several important priorities: attracting younger families, expanding community ministries, improving financial stability, and strengthening congregational relationships. Each deserves attention. But I wonder how the congregation has discerned which of these needs to come first, and what commitments members are prepared to make toward those goals."
That is not evading the question. It is practicing leadership.
The pastor is helping the committee move from a list of desired outcomes toward an understanding of shared responsibility.
And something else is happening.
The pastor is learning about the congregation.
Does the committee welcome thoughtful questions? Can its members acknowledge uncertainty? Are they willing to examine their assumptions? Do they understand that ministry depends upon the gifts and commitments of the whole congregation?
The answers matter.
A pastoral search is an exercise in mutual discernment. The congregation is learning about the pastor, but the pastor is also discovering whether this is a community in which they can serve faithfully.
A candidate who asks honest questions is not merely evaluating a potential employer. The candidate is beginning to establish the expectations and habits that will shape a pastoral relationship.
Can Honesty Really Compete?
This is the difficult question.
It would be comforting to say that honesty always wins, that search committees invariably recognize integrity, and that a candidate who tells the truth will ultimately be rewarded.
Experience tells us otherwise.
Some committees are impressed by confident promises and extraordinary claims. Some lack the experience or information needed to distinguish genuine accomplishments from exaggeration. Some are so anxious about their congregation's future that they are drawn toward candidates who offer certainty.
An honest pastor may lose opportunities to candidates who present more impressive, less accurate accounts of themselves.
We should acknowledge that reality rather than pretend virtue guarantees success.
But what does it mean to compete successfully for a pastoral call?
Is success receiving an invitation to serve, regardless of the expectations upon which that invitation rests? Or is success discerning a relationship in which a pastor and congregation can undertake faithful ministry together?
Those are not always the same thing.
A pastoral call secured through exaggeration creates expectations that the pastor will eventually have to live with. The congregation expects the extraordinary leader it believes it called. The pastor must either sustain the illusion or confront the disappointment that follows.
The apparent advantage of dishonesty can become a burden carried into the relationship itself.
Honesty offers no guarantee of receiving a call. It does, however, make possible something far more important than winning an interview: beginning ministry without having to defend a false account of who we are.
And it allows a pastor to discover whether the congregation is prepared for the kind of relationship the pastor actually hopes to establish.
There is another consideration.
A candidate who responds thoughtfully to unrealistic expectations, describes accomplishments accurately, and acknowledges the contributions of others is not merely being honest. That candidate is demonstrating an approach to leadership.
The interview itself becomes evidence of the pastor's ability to help people think more clearly, recognize their shared responsibilities, and engage difficult realities without defensiveness.
Those are not secondary qualities in pastoral ministry. They are central to it.
Perhaps the question is not simply whether honesty can compete with exaggeration, but whether we dare to recognize honesty as an essential expression of pastoral competence.
The Integrity of Our Calling
The apostle Paul writes to the Ephesians:
"Putting away falsehood, let all of us speak the truth to our neighbors, for we are members of one another." (Ephesians 4:25, NRSV)
Notice the reason Paul gives for truthfulness.
We belong to one another.
Honesty is not simply a private virtue that establishes our moral respectability. It is a responsibility arising from our relationships. We tell the truth because others depend upon us. After all, our decisions affect their lives, and because genuine community cannot flourish when people must continually wonder whether they are being misled.
This is especially important in pastoral ministry.
A congregation entrusts a pastor with its spiritual life, its vulnerabilities, its hopes, and sometimes its deepest conflicts. A pastor entrusts a congregation with a vocation, a livelihood, and a significant portion of their life.
Neither can responsibly enter that relationship through deception.
Christian Miller's research reminds us that dishonesty becomes particularly dangerous when it is rewarded and difficult to detect. The church should be deeply concerned about allowing those conditions to shape the way it calls its leaders.
But pastors need not wait for the entire call system to change before responding.
We can tell the truth about our accomplishments without claiming more credit than we deserve. We can acknowledge limitations without surrendering confidence in our gifts. We can discuss failures without becoming defensive. We can demonstrate leadership by helping search committees ask better questions and understand the realities of congregational ministry.
We can refuse to confuse self-promotion with faithful self-presentation.
And we can recognize that an interview is not simply an opportunity to secure a position. It is an opportunity to begin teaching a congregation what honest, accountable, shared leadership looks like.
The church cannot cultivate trustworthy leadership while rewarding the appearance of success more consistently than honesty, humility, accountability, and faithfulness.
Changing the culture of pastoral searches will eventually require congregations and presbyteries to examine the expectations and practices that shape the call process. But pastors can begin modeling a different approach now.
We can demonstrate that integrity is not the absence of accomplishment, confidence, or ambition. It is the willingness to represent ourselves and our ministries truthfully, even when a more impressive story might seem advantageous.
We can help congregations understand that faithful leadership is not the work of a heroic individual but the shared work of people responding together to God's call.
And we can enter the search process not merely asking how to persuade a congregation to call us, but discerning whether we can build a relationship grounded in truth.
The goal is not simply to be the candidate a congregation wants. It is to help a congregation recognize the kind of pastoral relationship it needs—and to discover together whether we are called to build it.
References
1. Christian B. Miller, The Honesty Crisis: Preserving Our Most Treasured Virtue in an Increasingly Dishonest World(Oxford University Press, 2026). See also "Honesty, Cheating, and Performativity," Conversing, November 10, 2026.
2. Megan Brenan, "Nurses Continue to Lead in Honesty and Ethics Ratings," Gallup, January 12, 2026. Gallup reported that only 27% of Americans rated clergy highly for honesty and ethical standards, a record low in its series. This measures public perceptions, not the actual prevalence of dishonesty among clergy.



