Young People Learn To Lead Through Leading

Churches worry about where the next generation of leaders will come from.
We see aging congregations. We struggle to recruit elders and deacons. Presbyteries search for pastors. Seminaries enroll fewer students preparing for traditional parish ministry. We look around the church and ask a reasonable question:
Who is going to lead the church after us?
Perhaps that is not the right question.
It assumes that leadership develops through channels we currently control. It may also assume too much about what leadership is.
We tend to imagine leaders as the people out front—the people with vision, authority, charisma, or responsibility for getting everyone else moving in the same direction. So when churches talk about developing young leaders, we can easily begin looking for younger versions of the leaders we already know.
But what if leadership is less about producing people who can stand out front and more about forming people who know how to bring what God has given them into the work we share?
Research and emerging work on young people, Christian formation, and leadership are pointing in that direction. Elizabeth Tamez Méndez emphasizes relationships, mutual learning, allyship, meaningful vocation, and experimentation. The Fuller Youth Institute has found that congregations effective in engaging young people distribute real responsibility and authority rather than keeping them centralized. Princeton Theological Seminary's Institute for Youth Ministry has experimented with models that integrate young people into the life of congregations, entrust them with meaningful work, and bring experience into conversation with theological reflection.[1][2][3]
A common thread runs through this work.
Young people are not simply preparing to become part of the church's ministry someday.
They are already part of what God is doing among us.
Formation Doesn't Have to Come Before Participation
Churches have traditionally been pretty good at creating educational pathways for young people.
First, we teach them.
Then we form them.
Then we give them opportunities to serve.
Eventually, if they demonstrate sufficient maturity, commitment, and competence, we may entrust them with leadership.
The sequence looks something like this:
formation → qualification → permission → leadership
There is wisdom in that. Responsibility requires knowledge, character, judgment, and accountability. But it describes only part of how formation actually happens.
Princeton's Log College Project worked with congregations to design and test new approaches to youth ministry. Rather than separating teenagers from the larger life of the congregation, participating churches developed intergenerational teams, integrated teenagers as leaders, experimented with ministry in their communities, and reflected theologically on what they were learning.[1]
The Fuller Youth Institute reached a related conclusion through its research on congregations that engage young people well. It calls one of the resulting practices “keychain leadership”: instead of keeping authority concentrated in a few hands, congregations give other people—including young people—meaningful access to responsibility and decision-making.[2]
Both suggest something important:
Participation itself is formative.
Young people develop judgment by making decisions.
They discover gifts by using them.
They learn cooperation by working with people whose gifts differ from their own.
They learn responsibility when other people actually depend upon them.
They discover limitations when something they try does not unfold as they expected.
They begin to discern vocation by paying attention to where their gifts, the needs of others, and God's calling seem to meet.
Formation, then, isn't a straight road toward a destination called “leader.”
It is dynamic and cyclical. We participate. We contribute. We experiment. We encounter surprises. We pray. We reflect on what happened. We bring our experience into conversation with Scripture and theology. We discover something about ourselves, our neighbors, and God. We accompany others and allow ourselves to be accompanied. Then we enter the work again, changed by what we have learned.
That isn't preparation for Christian life.
It is Christian life.
Give Young People Something That Matters
That doesn't mean asking a teenager to read Scripture on Youth Sunday and congratulating ourselves for developing leadership.
Participation is not the same thing as meaningful participation.
There is a difference between saying:
We need a young person on this committee.
and asking:
What are you seeing in our community that the rest of us may not be seeing?
Then listening to the answer.
Imagine a congregation concerned about teenage loneliness and isolation.
Adults could research the problem, develop a program, recruit volunteers, and invite teenagers to participate.
Or we could gather young people and begin somewhere else:
What are you seeing?
What do you think is happening?
Where do you see people hurting?
What might we try?
Then give them people who will work alongside them, resources they can actually use, access to the church's facilities and relationships, and enough freedom to discover that their first idea may not be their best one.
Something important has changed.
We aren't developing young people to participate in our ministry.
We are participating with young people in God's ministry.
When Things Don't Go as We Hoped
Meaningful participation carries risk.
If young people are going to discover their gifts by using them, some things they try will not turn out as they expected. An idea may fall flat. A project may not attract anyone. Something that looked simple may prove much harder than anticipated. A decision may have consequences nobody foresaw.
Sometimes we will simply have to say:
That didn't work.
That sentence does not have to become a verdict on the person who tried it.
And it does not mean God has stopped working.
Princeton's Institute for Youth Ministry describes an approach that includes experimentation, transformative learning, and theological reflection. Its Log College research involved congregations designing, testing, changing, and sometimes abandoning ideas as they learned what ministry required in their particular contexts.[1]
That sounds remarkably like life.
We act with the wisdom we have. Something happens. And then we have more to work with than we had before.
So rather than beginning with Did we succeed or fail?, we can ask:
What happened?
What surprised us?
Who was affected?
What did we learn?
What would we do differently?
What does our faith have to say about what happened?
Where might God still be at work?
Sometimes reflection will reveal that an idea simply wasn't very good.
Sometimes we will discover that someone was hurt and something needs to be repaired.
Sometimes circumstances changed.
Sometimes another person's gifts will prove more suited to the work than our own.
And sometimes a young person will discover:
I'm not very good at this.
That can be valuable knowledge because another discovery may follow:
But I am good at this.
The experience has not been wasted simply because the outcome disappointed us.
Christian faith makes an even larger claim. We do not believe God's presence depends upon our success. God remains present in disappointment, correction, repair, changed direction, and beginnings we could not see when our original plans fell apart.
Formation continues there, too
Accompany Rather Than Manufacture
This changes the role of adults.
Young people need experienced people in their lives. But experience doesn't have to create hierarchy.
An adult accompanier doesn't begin with:
I know what a leader looks like. Let me help you become one.
Accompaniment begins with curiosity:
What are you discovering?
Where did you feel most alive?
What was difficult?
What do other people seem to trust you with?
What happens when your gifts meet someone else's gifts?
What are you learning about yourself?
Where might God be in this?
The distinction matters.
Training begins with an outcome we have already defined.
Accompaniment leaves room for a vocation we cannot predict.
And eventually, accompaniment itself becomes reciprocal.
A teenager may accompany another young person trying something for the first time. Peers may accompany one another. A young adult may help an older adult understand a world the older person does not inhabit.
Experience remains different. Responsibility remains different. Expertise still matters.
But wisdom doesn't always travel in one direction.
Leadership Isn't Always Out Front
Perhaps this is where churches need to rethink leadership most deeply.
Good leadership isn't only found in the person who has the vision, gives the speech, chairs the committee, or gets everyone moving.
Sometimes leadership is recognizing that someone else's idea is better than mine.
Sometimes it is knowing how to cooperate.
Sometimes it asks the question the group has avoided.
Sometimes it is organizing the details after someone else has imagined the possibility.
Sometimes it helps two people hear one another.
Sometimes, it is possessing enough confidence in my own gifts that I don't need to control everyone else's.
And sometimes, mature leadership consists of saying:
You know more about this than I do. You lead. I'll help.
Following well is not the absence of leadership. It can be one of its most mature expressions.
That may be particularly important as younger generations enter institutions historically organized around hierarchy. Tamez Méndez describes emerging leadership in terms of collaboration, mutual learning, allyship, shared influence, and collective well-being.[3]
That doesn't mean authority disappears. Churches still need accountability. Some people have responsibilities that others do not. Expertise matters. Pastors, elders, teachers, administrators, and project leaders sometimes have to make decisions.
But authority can remain differentiated while leadership becomes increasingly shared.
The body of Christ may be a better image for this than any organizational chart.
Paul does not describe a body filled with aspiring heads. Paul describes differentiated gifts whose value emerges through their relationship to one another:
“The eye cannot say to the hand, ‘I have no need of you.’”—1 Corinthians 12:21, NRSVue
Leadership in such a community becomes less about becoming important and more about discovering:
What has God entrusted to me, and how can I bring it into relationship with what God has entrusted to you?
Prayer Belongs in the Middle of All of It
If we aren't careful, we can take contemporary ideas about collaboration, coaching, innovation, experimentation, and entrepreneurship and simply baptize modern leadership theory. Christian formation has a different center. We are not merely helping young people discover what they are good at. We are helping them discern:
Where is God at work, and what might God be calling me to contribute?
Prayer, therefore, isn't another component of leadership formation.
Prayer runs through all of it.
Prayer can be reflection:
God, what happened here?
Prayer can be discernment:
What are you asking of me?
Prayer can prepare us to act:
Give me courage.
Prayer can become action:
I will hold this person before God.
Prayer can happen in community:
What might God be asking of us together?
And sometimes prayer allows us to remain faithfully inside uncertainty when we do not yet know what an experience means.
Scripture, theology, worship, prayer, experience, and action begin speaking to one another.
That is not leadership training with a Christian veneer.
It is formation.
Help Young People Discover Their Place
Perhaps, then, our goal isn't to identify the young people who show “leadership potential.”
That language may already narrow what we are capable of seeing.
One young person discovers:
I can see where a group is getting stuck.
Another:
I can take someone else's idea and make it happen.
Another:
People trust me with things.
Another:
I ask questions other people don't seem willing to ask.
Another:
I can bring people together.
Another:
I see systems.
Another:
I make beautiful things.
Another:
I don't want to be out front, but give me responsibility, and I will make sure it gets done.
The church needs all of them.
Paul's claim about spiritual gifts isn't that everybody possesses the same gift or occupies the same role. It is almost exactly the opposite:
“To each is given the manifestation of the Spirit for the common good.”—1 Corinthians 12:7, NRSVue
The question, then, isn't simply:
Which of these young people are our future leaders?
It is:
What has God entrusted to each of them, and what might become possible when those gifts are offered together?
Calling Forth
These questions have led me to begin developing a set of resources:
Calling Forth
Discovering Our Gifts for the Common Good
Calling Forth isn't primarily about identifying leaders.
It is about helping congregations create the conditions in which young people can discover, exercise, and integrate their gifts in community.
I begin with a conviction rather than a program:
We cannot know in advance what God is calling a young person to become.
So the goal will not be to move young people through a sequence of leadership competencies. Instead, Calling Forth will explore a dynamic ecology of Christian formation: meaningful participation, contribution, experimentation, surprise, prayer, theological reflection, discernment, responsibility, cooperation, accompaniment, and being accompanied.
There may be broad movements within that formation, but they will not be steps on a ladder.
A young person may move among them and return to them repeatedly over years. And there may be no endpoint called “leader.”
The hope is something both simpler and larger:
A person increasingly able to recognize what God has entrusted to them, offer it confidently for the common good, receive the gifts of others, participate responsibly in shared work, reflect faithfully on experience, and remain open to where God may call next.
Some of those people may become pastors. Some may become elders or deacons.
Some may become teachers, nurses, engineers, artists, counselors, parents, organizers, scientists, tradespeople, entrepreneurs, public servants, or neighbors upon whom a community can depend. Christian vocation has never belonged only to the church's professionals.
The Church Doesn't Belong to Us to Give Away
Perhaps we need to retire the image of passing the baton.
A baton belongs to the runner carrying it until it is handed to the next runner.
The church was never ours in that sense. We inherited it too. We received Scripture we didn't write, theological traditions we didn't invent, communities we didn't establish, buildings we didn't construct, ministries others sacrificed to create, and stories of faith that began long before anyone knew our names.
Young people don't need to wait until we are finished with those things.
The church needs their imagination now.
They need our experience now.
We need their questions now.
They need our questions too.
We need their gifts now.
And all of us need the gifts of people whose experiences, abilities, and ways of seeing the world are different from our own. Perhaps developing the church's future leadership isn't primarily about figuring out who should lead next. Perhaps it begins by creating communities in which all of us can discover what God has given us and learn how to offer it together. The next generation isn't waiting somewhere outside the church for its turn.
They are already here.
The question is whether we will make enough room to discover together what the Spirit might call forth.

References
1. Princeton Theological Seminary, Institute for Youth Ministry, “The Log College Project” and IYM Research.The Log College Project used mixed-methods research with nearly 200 congregations in its first phase and followed 12 congregations closely for more than three years as they designed, tested, and implemented new forms of youth ministry. Its work emphasized integrating young people into congregational life, intergenerational participation, experimentation, and theological reflection.
2. Kara Powell, Jake Mulder, and Brad Griffin, Fuller Youth Institute, Growing Young: Six Essential Strategies to Help Young People Discover and Love Your Church. The Growing Young research identifies “keychain leadership” as a core commitment of congregations effective in engaging young people: rather than centralizing authority, congregations empower others, especially young people. Fuller subsequently describes this as sharing meaningful or “load-bearing” responsibility while providing encouragement and support.
3. Elizabeth Tamez Méndez, “Empowering the Next Generation: 5 Leadership Frameworks for a Changing World,” Leading Ideas, Lewis Center for Church Leadership, Wesley Theological Seminary, August 11, 2026. Tamez Méndez proposes five frameworks for engaging emerging leaders: relationships, mutual learning, allyship, attention to emerging leaders' passions, and support for entrepreneurial efforts.
Scripture quotations are from the New Revised Standard Version Updated Edition (NRSVue).



